On this page
Picking a website platform is one of those decisions that feels small on day one and becomes a big deal a year later — when you want to add a booking form, move to a new designer, or figure out why nobody can find you on Google. This guide compares the three platforms we get asked about most: WordPress, Squarespace and Wix.
The short answer: if your website needs to bring in customers and grow with your business, choose WordPress. It’s what we build on for most of our clients. Squarespace and Wix are fine for a quick, simple site you plan to manage entirely yourself — but you’ll trade away flexibility and ownership to get that simplicity.
The three platforms at a glance
- WordPress is open-source software that powers a large share of the websites on the internet. You own the site and its content, host it wherever you like, and can extend it with thousands of plugins.
- Squarespace is an all-in-one website builder with polished templates. Hosting, design and support come bundled in a monthly subscription.
- Wix is a drag-and-drop website builder, also sold as a monthly subscription, with an app marketplace for extra features.
Side-by-side comparison
| WordPress | Squarespace | Wix | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who owns the site | You do — move it to any host or developer | Lives on Squarespace’s platform | Lives on Wix’s platform |
| Design freedom | Unlimited — any layout, fully custom | Good, within template limits | Good, within editor limits |
| Features and add-ons | Almost anything: forms, booking, e-commerce, memberships, integrations | Built-in essentials, fewer add-ons | App market, but apps can add monthly fees |
| Search engine (SEO) control | Full control of titles, speed, schema and structure | Solid basics, limited advanced control | Solid basics, limited advanced control |
| Speed and performance | Excellent when built and hosted well | Decent, not adjustable | Decent, not adjustable |
| Ease of editing | Easy once it’s set up for you | Very easy | Very easy |
| Maintenance | Needs updates and backups (we handle this for clients) | Handled by Squarespace | Handled by Wix |
| Moving away later | Straightforward | Difficult — mostly a rebuild | Difficult — mostly a rebuild |
When WordPress is the right choice
WordPress is the best fit for most businesses and non-profits that want their website to do real work. Choose it if any of these sound like you:
- You want to be found on Google. WordPress gives you complete control over page titles, descriptions, site speed, structured data and URL structure — the things that move you up in search results.
- You expect to grow. Adding a service area page, a job application form, an online store or a client portal is a plugin or a small project, not a platform switch.
- You want to own what you pay for. Your site, your content and your data are yours. You can change hosts, designers or IT providers without starting over.
- You need integrations. CRMs, email marketing, scheduling, payment processors and phone systems all connect to WordPress.
- You want a site that looks like your brand — not like thousands of other sites using the same template.
The trade-off is upkeep: WordPress sites need regular updates, security monitoring and backups. That’s exactly what our website solutions cover, so you get the power of WordPress without having to manage it yourself.
When Squarespace or Wix can make sense
A hosted website builder can be a reasonable choice when:
- You need a simple, brochure-style site up quickly and plan to edit it entirely on your own.
- You have a very small budget and no plans to add features later.
- Search rankings and custom functionality aren’t a priority.
Just go in knowing the limits: you’re renting space on someone else’s platform, advanced features often mean extra monthly apps, and if you outgrow it, moving to another platform usually means rebuilding the site from scratch.
What about Square Online?
If you already take payments with Square, its free website builder, Square Online, is tempting — especially for restaurants and retail. It works well as a basic online ordering or product page tied to your Square account. As a main business website it has the same limits as Squarespace and Wix, with even less design and SEO control. A common setup we recommend is a WordPress website for your brand and search visibility, linked to Square for ordering and payments.
Questions to ask before you decide
- What should the website do for the business? Generate calls and leads, take bookings, sell products, or simply show you’re legitimate?
- Who will update it? You, your staff, or a partner who handles it for you?
- How important is Google? If customers search for your services locally, SEO control matters.
- Where will the business be in three years? New services, locations or staff usually mean new pages and features.
- What happens if you change providers? Make sure you can take your website with you.
If most of your answers point toward growth, leads and search visibility, WordPress is the platform that will keep up with you.
Already on Squarespace or Wix?
You don’t have to stay there. We regularly help businesses move from hosted builders to WordPress — rebuilding the design, carrying over content, and setting up redirects so you keep the search traffic you’ve already earned.
How Keylink IT can help
We design, build, host and maintain WordPress websites for businesses and non-profits across Nashville and Middle Tennessee. Updates, security, backups and support are handled for you, and your site sits alongside the rest of your IT with one local team. Call (615) 475-0145 or book a call and we’ll help you choose the right setup — even if it turns out to be a simple one.